I Need IT Support Now
AI Study
Shane

70% of Firms Use AI But Most See Zero Impact – What It Means for Houston SMBs

Executive And Employee Expectations Diverge Sharply On AI’s Employment Impact – Study Highlights Importance Of AI Implementation Strategy Over Simple Adoption

70% of Firms Use AI But Most See Zero Impact - What the NBER Study Means for Houston Businesses
2026 AI Research Report
70% of Firms Use AI But Most See Zero Impact - What It Means for Houston SMBs

A massive new NBER study of 6,000 executives across four countries separates AI hype from measurable business results.

TL;DR
A February 2026 NBER study of nearly 6,000 executives found that while 69% of firms actively use AI, over 80% report zero impact on employment or productivity over the past three years. Executives predict bigger changes ahead - 1.4% productivity gains and 0.7% job cuts by 2028.

A 20-person research team from Stanford, the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, the Bank of England, Deutsche Bundesbank, and Macquarie University just published what may be the most rigorous study of business AI adoption to date. The NBER Working Paper (No. 34836, February 2026) surveyed nearly 6,000 CFOs, CEOs, and senior executives across the US, UK, Germany, and Australia between November 2025 and January 2026.

The headline findings should grab the attention of every business owner in Houston and the Gulf Coast region: AI adoption is widespread, but actual business impact has been close to zero so far. That's a significant gap between expectation and reality - and it matters a lot for how small and mid-sized businesses should be thinking about their own AI strategies.

CinchOps is a managed IT services provider based in Katy, Texas, serving small and mid-sized businesses across the Houston metro area. CinchOps specializes in cybersecurity, network security, managed IT support, VoIP, and SD-WAN for businesses with 10-200 employees.

Why this report matters for Houston businesses: The gap between AI adoption and actual results tells us that having AI tools isn't the same as getting value from them. For SMBs in construction, legal, oil and gas, and other Houston industries, the question isn't whether to adopt AI - it's how to adopt it in ways that actually move the needle.
📊
What Makes This Study Different
Why the NBER data carries more weight than typical AI adoption surveys.

Most AI adoption numbers floating around come from paid internet surveys where it's unclear whether respondents are actually executives or providing informed answers. The McKinsey 2025 report, for example, estimated 88% AI adoption. The Census BTOS survey pegged it at around 9%. That's a 10x difference, and it highlights how much survey design matters.

The NBER study solved this three ways:

  • Verified executives: Respondents were initially recruited by phone to confirm their position and company, then moved into the survey panel. No paid anonymous clicks.
  • Institutional backing: The surveys were sponsored by the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, the Bank of England, and the Deutsche Bundesbank - which meant senior leaders actually responded.
  • Standardized questions: All four countries used identical questions timed to run in the same three-month window (November 2025 - January 2026).

The result is data that closely tracks GDP growth and employment figures going back a decade - meaning when these executives say something about their businesses, their answers line up with what actually happens.

🤖
AI Adoption Is Real - 69% of Firms Are Using It
Adoption varies by country, firm size, and industry - but the majority of businesses are in.

Across the four countries, 69% of businesses currently use some AI technology. The US leads at 78%, followed by the UK (71%), Germany (65%), and Australia (59%).

78%
US firms using AI
71%
UK firms using AI
65%
German firms using AI
59%
Australian firms using AI

The most common use case is text generation through large language models, used by 41% of firms. Data processing with machine learning and visual content creation each sit around 28-29%. Robotics (9%) and autonomous vehicles (3%) remain niche.

The study also found clear patterns in who's adopting:

  • Larger, more productive, and higher-paying firms are significantly more likely to use AI
  • Firms with younger leadership adopt AI at higher rates
  • Older firms and firms with older directors are less likely to be using AI
  • Finance, insurance, and professional services sectors lead adoption in the UK

Looking ahead, 75% of businesses expect to be using some AI technology within three years. The technology firms expect to use most going forward is data processing with machine learning - a shift from the current LLM-heavy pattern that suggests businesses are planning to move beyond text generation into data-driven operations.

👔
Executives Use AI 1.5 Hours Per Week
Personal usage by senior leaders is growing fast - but still modest.

Here's a number that surprised me: the average senior executive - we're talking CEOs, CFOs, and finance directors - uses AI for about 1.5 hours per week. A quarter of these leaders don't use it at all.

The breakdown looks like this: 28% of executives report zero AI use during a typical work week. The largest group (41%) uses AI for up to one hour per week. About 24% use it between 1-5 hours, and just 7% spend more than 5 hours per week with AI tools.

There's been real movement here, though. In the UK, the share of executives who don't use AI at all dropped from 45% in early 2025 to 25% by late 2025 - a 50% increase in average weekly AI use in less than a year. CEOs are also more likely to use AI than CFOs and other senior executives, which makes sense given the broader strategic questions AI addresses versus the more structured work of financial management.

The age factor is consistent: younger leaders use AI more. Companies with younger directors show higher personal AI use by executives, and younger firms show the same pattern.

📉
The Productivity Gap: 89% Report No Impact
Despite widespread adoption, AI has barely moved the needle on business productivity.

This is the finding that should cause some serious reflection. Across all four countries, 89% of firms report that AI has had no measurable effect on their sales per employee over the past three years. The average productivity boost is just 0.29%.

Compare that to individual task-level studies that find 15-30% productivity gains in specific settings. The gap between what AI can do in a controlled experiment and what it's actually delivering for businesses at scale is enormous.

There's some variation by sector. In the UK, information and communications firms reported the largest productivity gains at +0.8%, followed by professional and scientific firms at +0.5%. Construction and wholesale/retail reported near-zero impact.

💡

Why the Disconnect Between AI Hype and Business Results?

In 30+ years of managing IT for businesses, I've seen this pattern before. A technology gets adopted widely, but without the right infrastructure, training, and integration strategy, it sits underutilized. AI is powerful - but deploying it without a plan is like buying a bulldozer and using it to move a single wheelbarrow of dirt. The tool isn't the problem. The implementation is. That's where having the right CTO/CIO advisory services makes a real difference for businesses in Houston, Katy, and Sugar Land.

The forward-looking numbers tell a different story. Executives expect AI to boost productivity by 1.4% over the next three years. US firms are the most optimistic at +2.3%, followed by UK firms at +1.9%. German and Australian executives are more conservative at around +0.9% each.

If those predictions hold, we'd be looking at a meaningful reversal of the productivity growth slowdown that's plagued advanced economies for years. But given the track record of executives predicting AI impacts versus what actually materializes, some healthy skepticism seems appropriate.

💼
Employment Impact: Small So Far, Bigger Ahead
Over 90% of firms report no employment changes from AI - but executives predict cuts.

The employment picture mirrors productivity. Over 90% of firms across all four countries say AI has had zero effect on headcount over the past three years. The average impact rounds to essentially zero.

But ask executives what they expect over the next three years, and the picture shifts. Firms predict AI will reduce employment by 0.7% on average - the equivalent of roughly 1.75 million fewer jobs across the four countries surveyed. The largest expected cuts are in the UK (-1.4%) and US (-1.2%).

Metric All Firms US UK Germany Australia
Productivity Impact (Past 3 Years) +0.29% +0.24% +0.29% +0.24% +0.49%
Employment Impact (Past 3 Years) 0.00% -0.09% -0.14% +0.07% +0.32%
Expected Productivity (Next 3 Years) +1.44% +2.25% +1.86% +0.87% +0.92%
Expected Employment (Next 3 Years) -0.68% -1.19% -1.36% -0.06% +0.05%
Implied Output Change (Next 3 Years) +0.76% +1.06% +0.50% +0.81% +0.96%

A key detail: about two-thirds of expected employment reductions would come from hiring fewer new workers rather than laying off existing staff. That distinction matters for SMBs thinking about their workforce planning.

By sector, the accommodation/food and wholesale/retail industries expect the largest employment reductions - around -1.8% to -2% over three years in the UK. Construction, health, and recreational services expect smaller impacts. This lines up with what you'd expect: jobs with more routine, process-driven tasks are more exposed to AI-driven automation than those requiring physical presence and hands-on work.

🔍
Executives vs. Employees: A Major Perception Gap
Workers expect AI to create jobs. Their bosses expect AI to cut them.

The study also surveyed about 3,000 US employees through a separate survey, and the contrast with executive views is striking.

Employees use AI at roughly the same rate as executives - about 1.8 hours per week. But their expectations about AI's future impact on employment are completely opposite. Employees predict AI will increase employment by 0.5% over the next three years. Executives predict a decrease of 0.7% across all firms (1.2% for US firms specifically).

On productivity, the gap runs in the other direction. Employees expect a 0.9% productivity gain, while executives predict 1.4% (2.3% for US executives). So executives are more optimistic about productivity gains but also more likely to see those gains as coming at the cost of headcount.

This disconnect isn't academic. It has real implications for how businesses handle AI communication internally. If your team thinks AI will create opportunities while you're planning to reduce hiring, that's a recipe for trust problems down the road. Having an honest, early conversation about AI's role in your business - both the opportunities and the constraints - is worth the discomfort.

🏢
What This Means for Houston SMBs
Practical takeaways for businesses in the 10-200 employee range.

If you're running a construction company, law firm, or oil and gas operation in the Houston metro, this data should inform your AI strategy in several ways.

Don't panic about falling behind on AI. 69% adoption sounds high, but when 89% of those businesses report zero productivity impact, the real question isn't "are we using AI?" It's "are we using AI in ways that generate measurable value?" We see this pattern at least twice a month with Houston businesses - they've bought the tools, paid for the subscriptions, and have nothing to show for it because nobody thought about the integration piece.

Focus on specific use cases, not general adoption. The firms seeing actual results aren't the ones that gave everyone a ChatGPT subscription and called it a day. They're the ones who identified specific workflows where AI tools solve concrete problems: processing accounting data, drafting standard documents for engineering firms, or automating repetitive reporting tasks.

The real opportunity is in data processing, not text generation. While LLM text generation is the most common AI use today, firms expect data processing using machine learning to be the dominant use case going forward. For businesses in manufacturing, energy services, and wealth management, that shift toward data-driven AI is where the real productivity gains will come from.

Get your cybersecurity house in order before expanding AI use. Every AI tool your team uses is another potential data exposure point. We've already seen cases where employees are pasting client data into public AI tools without realizing the security implications. An AI usage policy and proper security guardrails aren't optional - they're a prerequisite.

🛡️
How CinchOps Can Help
Turning AI adoption into actual business results for Houston area SMBs.

Bridging the Gap Between AI Adoption and AI Results

The NBER study confirms what we've been telling Houston businesses for months: having AI tools isn't the same as getting value from them. CinchOps works with small and mid-sized businesses across Katy, Sugar Land, Cypress, The Woodlands, and the greater Houston area to build IT strategies that translate technology investments into measurable outcomes.

  • AI Readiness Assessment: We evaluate your current IT infrastructure to identify where AI tools can deliver real productivity gains for your specific industry and workflows
  • Security-First AI Integration: Every AI tool introduces new data exposure risks. We implement proper guardrails, usage policies, and security controls before expanding your AI footprint
  • Data Infrastructure: The shift toward data processing AI requires clean, accessible, well-organized data. We help get your systems ready for the next wave of AI capability
  • Business Process Automation: We identify repetitive tasks that AI and automation tools can handle reliably, so your team focuses on work that actually requires human judgment
  • Ongoing Managed IT Support: AI adoption is not a one-time project. We provide continuous monitoring, optimization, and support so your AI investments keep delivering returns
  • CTO/CIO Advisory: For businesses without a dedicated technology executive, we provide strategic guidance on when and how to invest in AI versus other technology priorities

The businesses that will gain competitive advantage from AI aren't the ones that adopted fastest. They're the ones that adopted smartest. CinchOps can help you be in that group.

100% Free

Know Your Business Security Score

Get a FREE comprehensive security assessment for your Houston area business. Understand vulnerabilities across your network, applications, DNS, and more.

Frequently Asked Questions
How many businesses are currently using AI technologies?
According to the February 2026 NBER study surveying nearly 6,000 executives across the US, UK, Germany, and Australia, approximately 69% of businesses currently use some form of AI technology. Adoption is highest in the US at 78% and expected to reach 75% across all four countries within three years.
Has AI actually improved business productivity so far?
The NBER study found that 89% of businesses reported no measurable productivity impact from AI over the past three years. The average productivity gain was just 0.29% across all surveyed firms. Executives do expect larger gains ahead, forecasting a 1.4% productivity increase over the next three years.
Will AI replace jobs at small and mid-sized businesses?
Firm executives predict AI will reduce employment by about 0.7% over the next three years, primarily through hiring fewer new employees rather than layoffs. Employees, in contrast, predict a 0.5% increase in jobs. For small and mid-sized businesses, the impact likely depends on how strategically AI is adopted alongside existing workflows.
What types of AI are businesses using most?
Text generation using large language models is the most widely adopted AI technology, used by 41% of firms surveyed. Data processing using machine learning follows at 28%, and visual content creation at 29%. Robotics and autonomous vehicles remain limited to specific industries at 9% and 3% respectively.
How can a managed IT provider help my Houston business adopt AI effectively?
A managed IT provider like CinchOps can assess your current technology infrastructure, identify where AI tools deliver real productivity gains for your specific industry, implement security guardrails around AI usage, and provide ongoing support to ensure adoption translates into measurable business results rather than wasted spend.

Discover More

Source: NBER Working Paper No. 34836, "Firm Data on AI" (February 2026)

Take Your IT to the Next Level!

Book A Consultation for a Free Managed IT Quote

281-269-6506